Grand Theft Auto VI is one of the best-reviewed games ever made, and one of the worst-rated by players on the same website. The GTA 6 Metacritic review bombing row has pushed the game’s user score to around 5.4 out of 10, even as critics gave it a near-perfect 99 out of 100, and the gap between the two numbers has become a story in its own right.
Rockstar’s game launched worldwide on 19 November 2026 for PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, and it broke sales records on day one: 24.58 million copies sold and an estimated $2.36 billion earned, as Newsy reported in GTA 6’s record first-day sales. But within a day of release, its Metacritic user score had collapsed, and accusations of review bombing followed.
GTA 6 Metacritic review bombing: how the score fell
On Metacritic, the PlayStation 5 version holds a Metascore of 99 from 152 critic reviews, every one of them positive. That ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, from 1998, as the highest-rated game in the site’s history. The user score tells a different story: it stood at about 5.4 out of 10 from 17,356 ratings on Friday, 20 November, split almost evenly between positive (46%), mixed (8%) and negative (47%) reviews. It had dipped as low as 3.7 out of 10 earlier that day before climbing back, and by Saturday morning it sat at about 5.5 from more than 34,800 ratings.
The trouble started before the game was even out. On 16 November, users noticed ratings appearing on the game’s Metacritic page ahead of launch, briefly dragging the user score to 6.5 out of 10. Metacritic removed the fake reviews and temporarily blocked further submissions, as Video Games Chronicle confirmed on 17 November. Once legitimate user reviews opened after the 19 November release, negative ratings flooded in again, and the review-bombing claims returned.
What players are complaining about
Some of the criticism is specific. Players have complained about performance, including the game running at 30 frames per second on the PS5 Pro, an issue critics also raised, and about the pacing of the story. Others have attacked the game’s story and characters on cultural grounds. And a large share of the lowest ratings say little about the game at all: Notebookcheck, which first reported the slide, pointed to a flood of zero-out-of-ten scores, entries that say nothing about the gameplay, and signs that some raters do not own the game.
That last point matters because of how Metacritic works. Anyone can rate a game there with only an email address: unlike the PlayStation Store or Steam, the site does not ask for proof that you bought it. The contrast is stark on Sony’s own store, where only people who bought the game can rate it. There, GTA 6 sits at 4.84 out of 5 from around 170,000 ratings.
The numbers behind the split
It is important to be clear about what is proven and what is not. There is no confirmed evidence of how many of the low ratings were submitted in bad faith, and neither Metacritic nor Rockstar had commented on the scores at the time of the reports. Not every negative review is review bombing: some players genuinely dislike parts of the game, and their complaints about performance and pacing overlap with what professional critics noted.
What is certain is that the user score will keep moving. It rose from 3.7 to above 5 within a day as more players rated the game, and more ratings will arrive as the launch weekend continues. For now, GTA 6 holds two records at once: tied for the highest critic score in Metacritic history, and one of the lowest user scores of any major release this year.
Read the original reporting at Forbes on the review bombing, Notebookcheck’s report on the user score, and Push Square on the PS5 user score. Newsy covered the launch itself in GTA VI’s global rollout.